BU-212: Future Batteries

Learn about up-and-coming batteries and what keeps them in laboratories for now.

Experimental batteries live mostly in sheltered laboratories and communicate to the outside world with promising reports, often to entice investors. Some designs show unrealistic results with anticipated release dates that move with time. Most concepts disappear from the battery scene and die gracefully in the lab without anyone hearing of their passing.

Few other products have similar stringent requirements as the battery, and the complexity puzzles venture capitalists who did well during the dot-com era and expect similar generous returns of their investment in only 3 years; battery development typically takes 10 years. Most venture capitalists don’t have the patience to wait and they pull back the money, leaving the developer in deep water. Raising capital is time consuming and many startups devote as much time and energy for this task as to doing research. (See BU-104: Getting to Know the Battery.)

Most experimental batteries in the lithium family have one thing in common; they use a metallic lithium anode to achieve a higher specific energy than what is possible with the oxidized cathode in lithium-ion, the battery that is in common use today.

Moli Energy was first to mass-produce a rechargeable Li-metal battery in the 1980s, but it posed a serious safety risk as the growth of lithium dendrites caused electric shorts leading to thermal runaway conditions. The local fire department knew exactly where to go on a fire alarm at the Moli plant; it was the battery warehouse. After a venting event injured a battery user, all lithium-metal packs were recalled in 1989. NEC and Tadiran tried to improve the design with limited success. Very few companies make rechargeable lithium-metal batteries and most offer the primary versions only. Research continues and a possible solution with new materials as part of the solid-state lithium could be on hand. This design is described further in this section.

Researchers have also developed an anode structure for Li-ion batteries that is based on silicon-carbon nanocomposite materials. A silicon anode could theoretically store 10 times the energy of a graphite anode, but expansions and shrinkage during charge and discharge make the system unstable. Adding graphite to the anode is said to achieve a theoretical capacity that is five times that of regular Li-ion with stable performance, however, the cycle life would be limited due to structural problems when inserting and extracting lithium-ion at high volume.

Meeting the eight basic requirements of the octagon battery is a challenge. Commercialization appears to dwell on a moving target that is always a decade ahead, but scientists are not giving up. Here are some of the most promising experimental batteries.
 

Lithium-air (Li-air)

Lithium-air provides an exciting new frontier because this battery promises to store far more energy than is possible with current lithium-ion technologies. Scientists borrow the idea from zinc-air and the fuel cell in making the battery “breathe” air. The battery uses a catalytic air cathode that supplies oxygen, an electrolyte and a lithium anode.

The theoretical specific energy of lithium-air is 13kWh/kg. Aluminum-air is also being tried, and it is a bit lower at 8kWh/kg. If these energies could indeed be delivered, metal-air, as the battery is also known, would be on par with gasoline at roughly 13kWh/kg. But even if the end product were only one quarter of the theoretical energy density, the electric motor with its better than 90 percent efficiency would make up for its lower capacity against the ICE with a thermal efficiency of only 25–30 percent.

Li-air was proposed in the 1970s and gained renewed interest in the late 2000s, in part because of advancements in material science and the endeavor to find a better battery for the electric powertrain. Depending on the materials used, lithium-air produces voltages of between 1.7 and 3.2V/cell. IBM, MIT, the University of California and other research centers are developing the technology.

As with other air-breathing batteries, the specific power may be low, especially at cold temperatures. Air purity is also said to be a challenge as the air we breathe in our cities is not clean enough for lithium-air and would need to be filtered. For all we know, the battery may end up with compressors, pumps and filters resembling a fuel cell, consuming 30 percent of its produced energy for auxiliary support to stay alive.

Another problem is the sudden death syndrome. Lithium and oxygen form lithium peroxide films that produce a barrier, which prevents electron movement and results in an abrupt reduction in the battery's storage capacity. Scientists are experimenting with additives to prevent the film formation. The cycle life will also need to improve; lab tests currently produce only 50 cycles.
 

Lithium-metal (Li-metal)

After several failed attempts to commercialize rechargeable lithium-metal batteries, research and limited manufacturing of this battery continues. In 2010, a trial lithium-metal with a capacity of 300Wh/kg was installed in an experimental electric vehicle. DBM Energy, the German manufacturer of this battery, claims 2,500 cycles, short charge times and competitive pricing if the battery were mass-produced.

An Audi A2 with these batteries drove over 450km (284mi) from Munich to Berlin on a single charge. There is a rumor that the car destroyed itself by a fire while on a laboratory test. Although the lithium-metal batteries passed the stringent approval tests, long-term safety remains an issue because metal filaments can form that might cause an electric short.

At 300Wh/kg, lithium-metal has one of the highest specific energies of lithium-based rechargeable batteries. NCA in the Tesla S 85 comes in at 250Wh/kg, LMO in the BMW i3 has 120Wh/kg and a similar chemistry in the Nissan Leaf has 80Wh/kg. The BMW i3 and Leaf batteries are made for high durability; Tesla achieves this by over-sizing.
 

Solid-state Lithium

The current Li-ion uses a graphite anode and this reduces the specific energy. Solid-state technology replaces graphite with pure lithium and substitutes the liquid electrolyte soaked in a porous separator with a solid polymer or a ceramic separator. This resembles the 1970 lithium-polymer that was discontinued due to safety and performance reasons. (See BU-206: Li-polymer: Substance of Hype.)

The solid-state battery shares similarity with lithium-metal and scientists are trying to overcome the problem of metallic filament formation with the use of dry polymer and ceramic separators. Additional challenges are achieving sufficient conductivity at cool temperatures and the need to improve the cycle count. Solid-state prototypes are said to only reach 100 cycles.

Solid-state batteries promise to store twice the energy compared to regular Li-ion, but the loading capabilities might be low, making them less suited for electric powertrains and applications requiring high currents. Targeted applications are load leveling for renewable energy source as well as EVs by cashing in on the short charge times that this battery allows. Research laboratories, including Bosch, predict that the solid-state battery might become commercially available by 2020 and be implemented in cars in 2025.

Lithium-sulfur (Li-S)

By virtue of the low atomic weight of lithium and the moderate weight of sulfur, lithium-sulfur batteries offer a very high specific energy of 550Wh/kg, about three times that of Li-ion. Li-S also has a respectable specific power of 2,500W/kg. During discharge, lithium dissolves from the anode surface and reverses itself when charging by plating itself back onto the anode. Li-S has a cell voltage of 2.10V, offers good cold temperature discharge characteristics and can be recharged at –60°C (–76°F). The battery is environmentally friendly; sulfur, the main ingredient, is abundantly available. A price of US$250 per kWh is said to be possible.

A typical Li-ion has a graphite anode that hosts lithium-ions much like a hotel books guests. On discharge, the battery releases the ions to the cathode, replicating guests checking out in the morning. In Li-S, graphite is replaced by lithium metal, a catalyst that provides double duty as electrode and supplier of lithium ions. The Li-S battery gets rid of “dead weight” by replacing the metal oxide cathode used in a Li-ion with cheaper and lighter sulfur. Sulfur has the added advantage of double-booking lithium atoms, something Li-ion cannot do.

A challenge with lithium-sulfur is the limited cycle life of only 40–50 charges/discharges as sulfur is lost during cycling by shuttling away from the cathode and reacting with the lithium anode. Other problems are poor conductivity, a degradation of the sulfur cathode with time and poor stability at higher temperatures. Since 2007, Stanford engineers have experimented with nanowire. Trials with graphene are also being done with promising results.

Sodium-ion (Na-ion)

Sodium-ion represents a possible lower-cost alternative to Li-ion as sodium is inexpensive and readily available. Put aside in the late 1980s in favor of lithium, Na-ion has the advantage that it can be completely discharged without encountering stresses that are common with other battery systems. The battery can also be shipped without having to adhere to Dangerous Goods Regulations. Some cells have 3.6V, and the specific energy is about 90Wh/kg with a cost per kWh that is similar to the lead acid battery. Further development will be needed to improve the cycle count and solve the large volumetric expansion when the battery is fully charged.

Last updated 2016-07-04
 

*** Please Read Regarding Comments ***

Comments are intended for "commenting," an open discussion amongst site visitors. Battery University monitors the comments and understands the importance of expressing perspectives and opinions in a shared forum. However, all communication must be done with the use of appropriate language and the avoidance of spam and discrimination.

If you have a suggestion or would like to report an error, please use the "contact us" form or email us at: BatteryU@cadex.com.  We like to hear from you but we cannot answer all inquiries. We recommend posting your question in the comment sections for the Battery University Group (BUG) to share.

Or Jump To A Different Article

Basics You Should Know
The Battery and You
Batteries as Power Source

Comments

On September 8, 2011 at 5:36pm
David Cockburn wrote:

Do they make a 6 V battery for inverter use.

On September 28, 2011 at 5:08pm
Jeff Manny wrote:

Dear Sir,

I am planning to do my PhD on a battery here in Australia
Initially i was thinking about research on Plasma batteries and now after coming to your fantastic site interested about couple of more batteries such as Lithium-metal (Li-metal)
andLithium-sulfur (Li-S)
Would you please guide me about my research battery topic as i am aware that you know more than me which battery has got a better scope of success in the future

 

 

 

 

 

On February 24, 2012 at 3:43am
vinod wrote:

Dear Sir,

I am planning to do my PhD on a battery here in India.
Sir, your website has very good information about the batter.
Could you please tell me sir, what are the major’s problems you are facing for in li-ion battery today?
Alternatively, please tell me sir in which area of the battery the more research work needed the improving in battery
Waiting for positive response.
Thanks.

On December 10, 2012 at 2:58am
dinesh wrote:

I am planning to do my PhD on a battery here in UK.
Sir, I got very useful information from your website about battery.
Sir, could you please tell me in which area/part of the battery needs more research work to store the power ( in power storage battery ) is there any possibility to make a power storage battery design like: what I am thinking is bringing the parts in battery which are useless at end of battery in a same location, is it possible are not, Sir.

Waiting for your positive response.

Thanks.

On June 1, 2013 at 7:02pm
john corrie wrote:

have you compared/reviewed zinc bromide batteries? as an investor in redflow ltd I would be most interested in any comments, thanks JC

On September 10, 2014 at 2:45am
mjd wrote:

Dear Sir
I am planning to do my PhD on a battery. I am a frosh PhD student in mechanical engineering. could you please tell me in which area/part of the battery needs more research work specially in thermal field in battery. Please guide me.

Waiting for your response.

Thanks.

On November 30, 2014 at 6:33am
Radhey Shyam Meena wrote:

Dear Sir,
First of all thank you very much for this super website on battery. currently i am m.tech scholar in power system from Rajasthan technical university kota india.  could you please tell me in which area/part of the battery needs more research work specially in thermal field in battery. and also tell me camparision study of different battery Please guide me.
Waiting for your response.
Thanks.

On November 3, 2015 at 2:25pm
Gurr wrote:

I would thouroughly enjoy a section on the recent hype on magnesium batteries.

Also…these PhD’s and their “Dear Sir” letters are kind of freaky and bot-like.

On April 7, 2016 at 5:37pm
Caitlin wrote:

The theoretical limit for lithium sulfur is ~2,600 Wh/kg (versus the max ~550 Wh/kg for lithium ion). I think the numbers listed above might have been mistaken.

Thanks for all of the info!!

^^ I agree. the “dear sir"s are eerie

On September 23, 2016 at 1:41am
syafiq wrote:

i want doing a research about rechargable battery. Can be a solar energy and kinetic energy combined and supply to a rechargable battery? We used a remote control car battery for that. we doing this research for replace the usage of fuel in real car and turn it to battery power

On October 9, 2016 at 10:09am
Nagaraja.D.H wrote:

I intended to manufacture Lithium based battery in In Bangalore-INDIA.

will you guided in all aspects and oblige

On November 19, 2016 at 9:06am
George Caraghiaur wrote:

Can you comment on the aqueous ion battery, such as Aquion’s?